Masculinity and femininity are not purely socially constructed concepts but are grounded in evolutionary origins. Key distinctions between males and females from an evolutionary psychology perspective emphasize behavioral differences, including males' propensity for risk-taking, socio-sexuality, and aggression. These traits are deeply rooted in the evolutionary pressures faced by our ancestors.
Second-wave feminism questioned traditional gender roles, yet debates persist about inherent biological differences between men and women. The competitive and hierarchical behaviors observed among men contrast with the social dynamics and cooperative tendencies often found among women, a distinction frequently explored within feminist philosophy.
As discussions around gender identity, ‘trans rights’, and the medicalization of minors intensify, scrutiny of academic philosophy and bioethics is becoming more important regarding gender-affirming care and trans-related issues, particularly due to the frequent sidelining of alternative perspectives in these debates.
In this bonus episode for premium subscribers, Alex reflects on the fundamental distinctions between masculinity and femininity, emphasizing the role of evolutionary psychology in shaping gendered behaviors. He critiques the challenges within feminist philosophy, particularly its resistance to critical perspectives, and expresses concern over the lack of philosophical inquiry into gender-affirming care, highlighting an absence of diverse viewpoints in the field.
“The problem as I see it with feminist philosophy is that it really is the only area of philosophy where very broadly you have to sign up to some worldview in order to participate. So in all other areas of philosophy, everyone is welcome. There are plenty of religious people who work in the philosophy of religion, but you absolutely do not have to be a believer in order to be a member of that intellectual community.”
Watch our full length episode with Alex Byrne:
Listen to this episode with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Gender: A Wider Lens to listen to this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.
