Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Julie Grant's avatar

When Kids Say They're Trans is a fantastic resource! I love the nuanced, compassionate way you talk about the issue. It demonstrates that it is possible to be both compassionate and reality-based. It is a much needed breath of fresh air in an environment that can often feel suffocating. Thank you!!

Expand full comment
Claire Rae Randall's avatar

This is a comment on the article about Dr 'Death' Macchiarini since I am not a subscriber I can't comment on that thread. What I want to say is that comparing gender treatment to the kind of things that doctor did is completely off the charts wrong. Whilst gender ideology and much of what we know about transgenderism is mere contagion the actual phenomenon of transsexualism does exist, see Ramachandran, Zhou, McGeoch, Bakkar and Diamond for the papers, including brain studies and separated twin studies.

When I tweeted to Genspect, to which organisation I believe you are affiliated, I received a reply to the effect that since I was a transsexual why was I approaching them, since they did not agree with the existence of my condition.

If you will not engage with the people that you are criticising then you are demonstrating how weak your case is.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts